NFL 1ST & GOAL · THE LOCKER ROOM SPORTS REPORT

THE LOCKER ROOM SPORTS REPORT · NFL 1ST & GOAL — SPECIAL REPORT

THE COMPARISON OF 12 QUARTERBACKS WHO HAVE STARTED AT LEAST 80% OF THEIR TEAM'S GAMES, HAVE NEVER WON A SUPER BOWL, AND ARE CONSIDERED BETTER THAN DAK PRESCOTT — BUT THE STATS SAY OTHERWISE

2014–2018 NFL DRAFT CLASSES | CAREER STATISTICS | DRAFT VALUE

WHY PATRICK MAHOMES AND SAM DARNOLD WERE EXCLUDED

Patrick Mahomes and Sam Darnold are two notable quarterbacks excluded from this comparison because both have won Super Bowls. Mahomes won three championships with Kansas City, while Darnold helped lead Seattle to victory in Super Bowl LX in February 2026. They are not included in the statistical rankings.

This article examines the following 12 selected quarterbacks who have not won a Super Bowl. The 80% starting-games standard refers to their established periods as starting quarterbacks, not every season in their careers, including backup seasons. The 12-player list is fixed for this comparison and should not be represented as an exhaustive list of every qualifying quarterback in the NFL.

Editorial scope: the headline states the report’s argument. “Established periods” are not defined as a reproducible season-by-season screening rule here, so the 80% phrase is not a verified career-wide eligibility claim. Being “considered better” is an opinion, not a measured consensus. All 12 named quarterbacks remain included.

Common results cutoff: October 22, 2026, 11:59 p.m. Eastern.
Career regular-season statistics and completed postseason statistics are separate. Reviewed October 23, 2026 · 8:10 PM ET. No 2026 preseason statistics are included.

THE 12 QUARTERBACKS

Quarterback / draft positionDraft year
Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)2014
Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)2014
Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)2014
Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)2015
Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)2015
Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)2016
Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)2016
Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)2017
Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)2017
Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)2018
Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)2018
Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)2018

Ten were first-round selections, one was a second-round selection, and Dak Prescott was the only fourth-round selection.

THE STATISTICAL COMPARISON

Every ranking and graph includes all 12 quarterbacks and their draft round and overall pick. Open any category below; the full numeric table follows its graph. Gold highlights Dak Prescott. Regular-season percentages and ratios are calculated from verified totals, not averaged season percentages.

01 Career passing yards REGULAR SEASON

Highest to lowest.

RankQuarterback / draft positionCareer passing yards
1Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)41,245
2Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)41,107
3Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)37,628
4Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)31,606
5Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)29,140
6Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)25,749
7Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)23,575
8Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)19,078
9Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)18,219
10Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)17,649
11Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)15,182
12Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)13,028
02 Career passing touchdowns REGULAR SEASON

Highest to lowest.

RankQuarterback / draft positionCareer passing touchdowns
1Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)268
2Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)257
3Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)253
4Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)229
5Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)199
6Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)193
7Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)163
8Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)130
9Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)111
10Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)103
11Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)78
12Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)75
03 Completion percentage REGULAR SEASON

Highest to lowest.

RankQuarterback / draft positionCompletion percentage
1Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)66.9%
2Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)66.3%
3Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)66.1%
4Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)65.9%
5Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)65.1%
6Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)64.9%
7Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)64.4%
8Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)64.1%
9Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)63.5%
10Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)62.8%
11Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)60.9%
12Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)59.3%
04 Career interceptions REGULAR SEASON

Fewest to most. Career totals depend on playing time; use interception percentage for the regular-season efficiency comparison.

RankQuarterback / draft positionCareer interceptions
1Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)47
2Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)48
3Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)50
4Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)57
5Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)62
6Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)75
7Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)97
8Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)98
9Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)102
10Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)103
11Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)112
12Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)118
05 Career passer rating REGULAR SEASON

Highest to lowest.

RankQuarterback / draft positionCareer passer rating
1Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)102.7
2Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)98.3
3Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)97.9
4Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)97.3
5Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)94.7
6Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)92.8
7Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)90.9
8Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)90.3
9Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)90.1
10Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)86.9
11Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)85.9
12Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)80.6
06 Starting quarterback regular-season winning percentage REGULAR SEASON

Highest to lowest. Calculated as (wins + 0.5 × ties) ÷ starts. These are team results in quarterback starts, not an individual-only performance grade.

RankQuarterback / draft positionStarting quarterback regular-season winning percentageStarting W–L–TStarts
1Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)71.2%79-32-0111
2Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)69.9%93-40-0133
3Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)59.9%93-62-1156
4Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)59.0%85-59-1145
5Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)54.4%31-26-057
6Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)52.6%41-37-078
7Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)50.8%33-32-065
8Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)47.2%58-65-0123
9Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)45.6%77-92-0169
10Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)44.0%37-47-084
11Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)41.4%38-54-193
12Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)32.9%24-49-073
07 Career rushing yards REGULAR SEASON

Highest to lowest.

RankQuarterback / draft positionCareer rushing yards
1Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)6,666
2Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)4,961
3Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)2,502
4Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)2,338
5Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)2,188
6Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)1,766
7Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)1,648
8Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)1,366
9Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)1,180
10Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)956
11Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)848
12Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)612
08 Career rushing touchdowns REGULAR SEASON

Highest to lowest.

RankQuarterback / draft positionCareer rushing touchdowns
1Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)87
2Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)36
3Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)31
4Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)20
5Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)19
6Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)13
6Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)13
6Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)13
9Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)12
10Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)11
11Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)8
12Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)7
09 Passing touchdown-to-interception ratio REGULAR SEASON

Highest to lowest.

RankQuarterback / draft positionPassing touchdown-to-interception ratio
1Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)3.39:1
2Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)2.63:1
3Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)2.61:1
4Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)2.60:1
5Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)2.34:1
6Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)2.29:1
7Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)1.93:1
8Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)1.79:1
9Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)1.62:1
10Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)1.60:1
11Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)1.38:1
12Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)1.37:1
10 Interception percentage REGULAR SEASON

Highest to lowest.

RankQuarterback / draft positionInterception percentage
1Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)1.88%
2Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)1.91%
3Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)1.94%
4Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)1.94%
5Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)2.02%
6Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)2.26%
7Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)2.30%
8Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)2.48%
9Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)2.54%
10Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)2.55%
11Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)2.85%
12Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)3.47%
11 Postseason quarterback wins as starter POSTSEASON

Highest to lowest. Wins belong to teams; this records results in games the quarterback started. Ties count as half a win. Relief wins are excluded. Winston has zero playoff starts, so his starting win percentage is N/A.

RankQuarterback / draft positionPostseason quarterback wins as starterStarting W–LStarts
1Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)88-715
2Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)44-59
3Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)33-58
4Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)22-35
4Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)22-13
4Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)22-57
7Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)11-23
7Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)11-12
9Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)00-11
9Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)0No starts0
9Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)00-22
9Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)00-11
12 Postseason starting winning percentage POSTSEASON

Highest to lowest. Wins belong to teams; this records results in games the quarterback started. Ties count as half a win. Relief wins are excluded. Winston has zero playoff starts, so his starting win percentage is N/A.

RankQuarterback / draft positionPostseason starting winning percentageStarting W–LStarts
1Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)66.7%2-13
2Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)53.3%8-715
3Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)50.0%1-12
4Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)44.4%4-59
5Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)40.0%2-35
6Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)37.5%3-58
7Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)33.3%1-23
8Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)28.6%2-57
9Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)0.0%0-11
9Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)0.0%0-22
9Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)0.0%0-11
—Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)N/A — no startsNo starts0
13 Postseason passing yards POSTSEASON

Highest to lowest.

RankQuarterback / draft positionPostseason passing yards
1Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)3,915
2Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)2,450
3Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)1,962
4Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)1,753
5Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)1,338
6Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)870
7Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)594
8Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)502
9Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)463
10Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)310
11Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)149
12Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)56
14 Postseason passing touchdowns POSTSEASON

Highest to lowest.

RankQuarterback / draft positionPostseason passing touchdowns
1Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)29
2Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)14
3Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)12
4Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)10
5Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)9
6Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)4
6Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)4
8Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)3
9Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)2
10Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)1
10Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)1
12Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)0
15 Postseason interceptions POSTSEASON

Fewest to most. Small postseason samples and unequal opportunities matter.

RankQuarterback / draft positionPostseason interceptions
1Blake Bortles (Rd 1, Pk 3)0
1Jameis Winston (Rd 1, Pk 1)0
1Mitchell Trubisky (Rd 1, Pk 2)0
1Teddy Bridgewater (Rd 1, Pk 32)0
5Derek Carr (Rd 2, Pk 36)1
5Deshaun Watson (Rd 1, Pk 12)1
5Marcus Mariota (Rd 1, Pk 2)1
8Baker Mayfield (Rd 1, Pk 1)3
9Jared Goff (Rd 1, Pk 1)5
10Josh Allen (Rd 1, Pk 7)6
11Dak Prescott (Rd 4, Pk 135)7
11Lamar Jackson (Rd 1, Pk 32)7

DAK PRESCOTT’S POSITION IN THE VERIFIED COMPARISON

CategoryDak’s rank among these 12
Career passing yards3 of 12
Career passing touchdowns3 of 12
Completion percentage1 of 12
Career interceptions7 of 12
Career passer rating3 of 12
Starting quarterback regular-season winning percentage4 of 12
Career rushing yards5 of 12
Career rushing touchdowns3 of 12
Passing touchdown-to-interception ratio3 of 12
Interception percentage4 of 12
Postseason quarterback wins as starter4 of 12
Postseason starting winning percentage8 of 12
Postseason passing yards3 of 12
Postseason passing touchdowns2 of 12
Postseason interceptions11 of 12

These ranks use the same cutoff and include all 12 selected players. Equal numeric values share a rank; names break display-order ties only. N/A is unranked. Rounded percentages can look tied even when unrounded values differ. No undisclosed composite “overall quarterback” score is used.

WHY DAK PRESCOTT MAY BE THE BEST DRAFT VALUE

Dak Prescott was selected by Dallas in the fourth round of the 2016 NFL Draft, 135th overall. Unlike the ten first-round quarterbacks and one second-round quarterback in this comparison, Prescott entered the league without the same draft investment or expectations.

Yet Prescott immediately became a starting quarterback, earned NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year honors in 2016 and developed into a long-term franchise quarterback.

The central argument is not simply how many passing yards or touchdowns he has accumulated. It is the return Dallas received from the 135th selection.

When a fourth-round quarterback produces statistics competitive with quarterbacks selected first, second, third or seventh overall, that performance deserves serious consideration in evaluating draft value.

Prescott’s sustained passing production and efficiency strengthen his case. Later contracts and postseason performance should be evaluated separately rather than confused with the value of his original draft selection.

IS DAK PRESCOTT THE BEST OVERALL QUARTERBACK?

The answer requires more than passing totals. Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson provide exceptional rushing production and have earned league MVP recognition. Jared Goff offers significant passing production and postseason experience.

Prescott’s passing statistics are competitive, but postseason results, individual awards, rushing ability, efficiency and starting win percentage must all be considered.

It is reasonable to argue that Prescott is among the strongest draft values in this group. Claiming that he is unquestionably the best overall quarterback would go beyond what the passing statistics alone prove.

THE LOCKER ROOM SPORTS REPORT VERDICT

The comparison challenges the assumption that a quarterback selected early in the first round must be better than a quarterback selected in the fourth round.

Dak Prescott’s career demonstrates why draft position and quarterback performance are not the same thing. The Dallas Cowboys found a franchise quarterback with the 135th overall selection, and his passing production compares favorably with numerous players drafted much earlier.

The strongest conclusion is that Dak Prescott deserves serious recognition as one of the best quarterback draft values from the 2014–2018 classes.

Whether he is the best overall quarterback among these 12 remains a debate that should be decided using complete, verified passing, rushing, winning and postseason statistics.

METHODS, SOURCES & SMALL-SAMPLE CONTEXT

Regular-season completion percentage = completions ÷ attempts; interception percentage = interceptions ÷ attempts; touchdown-to-interception ratio = passing TD ÷ interceptions. Career passer rating uses the NFL-published career rating. Totals include relief passing and rushing; starting records only include starts. Kneel-downs are included in official rushing totals.

Postseason passing totals include relief appearances. Goff’s relief contribution in the 2020 wild-card win is included in his passing totals, but that game is not credited as a Goff start. Winston’s one postseason attempt was a 56-yard touchdown; he has no playoff starts. Bridgewater’s passing totals include a 2024 relief completion as well as his 2015 start. Zero playoff interceptions can reflect tiny samples, not superior career efficiency.

Passing yards, touchdowns and interception totals have unequal career-length exposure. This fixed cohort is not a complete survey of NFL quarterbacks, and no adjusted draft-surplus valuation model is being claimed. The draft-value verdict is editorial analysis.

Open source register · all 12 quarterbacks

Starting-record source register

Bridgewater’s retired career totals are cross-checked against the Lions’ 2026 signing announcement, career statistical record and CBS career table. Quarterback starting records and postseason starts are cross-checked separately from passing totals; see the public data register.

Championship context: Seattle’s February 8, 2026 championship report · Mahomes club biography. Draft value: Prescott’s Cowboys biography. Awards: Ravens MVP history.

Public comparison data and source register

Highlights & standout plays

Official videos selected for this sport. Older selections are explicitly marked as archives.

Selection reviewed Saturday, October 24, 2026 · 2:38 AM ET. Daily review does not mean every sport has a new clip every day. Tap Play to load the video; regional or publisher restrictions may apply.

Official highlight

New England Patriots vs. Chicago Bears Game Highlights | 2026 NFL Season

New England Patriots · Published October 22, 2026

Selected recent footage; see its original date above.

Watch on the official YouTube channel ↗